Sticky toffee meets pecan pie? Not quite, but this pecan toffee cake gives you the best of both: a soft, date-rich sponge with warming spices and a generous topping of toasted pecans.

Pecan – nuts?
They are a hard nut to crack! Also literally, as their name is derived from a Native American, Algonquin word meaning ‘a nut cracked with a stone’. They are native to North America and these days also grow but quite reluctantly in southern Europe, so the south-central US states are still the leading producer of those nuts.
Which are not actually nuts in a botanical sense, but drupes, related to peach and plum as well as walnut (the last also not technically nuts). That’s because the tree yields pecan fruit wrapped in a green husk that later dries out, surrounding the hard shell which hides the edible seed – the kernel. Apparently about the only true nuts are hazelnuts and chestnuts. Why must botanists complicate things so, I don’t know.
Pie and more
Pecans are the American cousins of walnuts, only a little harder to crack. Whatever your implements, pecans will annoyingly crack across the middle, thus dashing the hopes of beautifully intact halves emerging from the shell. Which is probably why shelled nuts are much more popular as snacks and in recipes even though freshly cracked ones are a lot nicer.
In cooking, it’s pecan pie that you’ll immediately think of – and it even has the title of the official state pie in Texas. But pecans can be used in a huge multitude of dishes and desserts apart from the pie. Like the twist on a sticky toffee recipe below!
Pecan toffee cake
This cake is beyond delicious, and it can be served both as a pudding as well as a cake with coffee or for afternoon tea.
And it’s simple enough to make, as long as you have a large amount of shelled pecans. They don’t need to be all intact halves, especially that some of them are going to be ground. You can try to reserve the halves for the topping but even if in pieces, they will work just as well.
Grinding the nuts
About a third of the amount required in the recipe needs to be finely ground. The absolutely best apparatus for this is a manual nut mill – cheap to buy, and it can also be used to grind cheese or chocolate. You can use a food processor but take care not to turn them into a paste. And a repurposed coffee grinder will work likewise, with just a few pulses of the motor.
What dates for the recipe?
A toffee cake must use dates, of course. If you have standard, dried dates of a no-name variety, soak them, chopped, in boiling water with a pinch of bicarbonate of soda, then drain. If you want to splash and use the crème de la crème of the date world, jammy and soft medjool, they only need tearing roughly into pieces – they’ll melt in the batter like an angel.
How to make the batter
Once you’ve prepared the ground pecans and the dates, it’s fairly easy. Butter beaten with sugar until airy is the first step. You can add the spices to this mix or conventionally stir them into flour.
The next step is the eggs, lightly beaten, the drained or just chopped dates and the ground pecans – all added at once and beaten briefly until smooth.
And you can also beat the flour in, or fold it in with a spatula which will make for a lighter texture.
Topping with pecans
All the remaining, whole or in chunks, pecans should be piled on top of the batter, loosely scattered without pressing them in. You might be worried that it’s too much or they’ll burn but trust the recipe – they will emerge beautifully burnished, toasted and fragrant.
That’s also the obvious reason why they should not be toasted beforehand, which I instinctively thought of doing when I first encountered the recipe on BBC Good Food. But that would be indeed a recipe for burnt nuts, at least the ones forming the topping.
Substitutions
I love using fine wholemeal flour for cakes like this – apart from adding extra fibre to the dessert, it enhances the nutty, earthy, sticky-toffee vibe. But if plain flour is what you have or prefer, by all means use that.
As I already said medjool dates are not essential – any dates, even ready-chopped and quite hard will work as long as they are soaked and softened. And if you don’t like dates, trust me – you’d never know they were in the cake.
Instead of light muscovado sugar you can use light brown, dark muscovado or dark brown.
And of course instead of pecans walnuts can be used, as well as hazelnuts or almonds – with delightfully nuanced changes to the flavour.
How to serve pecan toffee cake
The cake is utterly delicious and it makes a very fitting pudding. For that, either cut it when warm from the oven or briefly warm it up in the microwave if serving the following day. A drizzle of maple syrup and a spoonful of crème fraiche will make a blissful sauce. Vanilla or caramel ice cream won’t go amiss either.
But the cake keeps well and can be happily scoffed cold, with or without maple syrup, with a cuppa.
More pecan recipes
Maple and pecan sticky buns, baked upside down, flavoured with cinnamon and cardamom. It's a rich and sticky, sweet and spicy bliss, best enjoyed warm!
Date and nut squares are made with chunks of medjool dates and packed with a mix of almonds, pecans and pistachio in rich, chewy batter. There’s a reason why these are called ‘food for gods’.
Pecan nuts are put into good use in these Linzer bars with easy, nutty shortcrust pastry and jam filling. The bars are one of those ultimately comforting sweets: a posh version of jammy shortbread bars.
More date-toffee cake recipes
Honey cake with dates and apples from Nigella Lawson’s collection is not only suitable for Rosh Hashanah: it’s simply the perfect autumnal cake. Or for any time of the year.
Dates and dark brown sugar are key to a sticky toffee pudding, the best beloved British dessert and deservedly so. This recipe is for an easy sticky toffee pudding cake topped with nuts and drenched in toffee sauce.
This sweet and tangy riff on sticky toffee is a crowd-pleaser, perfect for any occasion. With a moist and tender crumb and rich flavours of tamarind and dates, it’s a must-try for anyone who loves sticky toffee and/or dates.